Unfair Puppy Rehoming: Is it an Extreme Punishment for Not Doing Chores?

When it comes to disciplining children, parents often resort to various methods to teach their kids the importance of responsibility and accountability. However, when these methods involve the welfare of a living being, such as a pet, the line between discipline and cruelty can become blurred. A recent incident involving a mother rehoming her daughter’s puppy as punishment for not doing chores has sparked a debate on whether such actions are justified or extreme. This article aims to delve into this issue, exploring the ethical implications and potential consequences of such actions.

Understanding the Situation

Before passing judgment, it’s crucial to understand the context. In this case, a mother gave away her daughter’s puppy because the daughter refused to do her chores. The puppy had been with the family for a few months. The mother’s intention was likely to teach her daughter about responsibility. However, the question arises: Is this an overkill?

The Ethical Implications

From an ethical standpoint, using a living being as a tool for discipline is problematic. Pets are not objects; they are sentient beings capable of forming emotional bonds with their owners. When a pet is rehomed, it can experience stress and anxiety. Moreover, it’s unfair to the child who has formed an emotional bond with the pet. The sudden loss can lead to feelings of guilt, sadness, and even depression.

The Consequences

Aside from the emotional impact, such actions can have long-term consequences. It can lead to a breakdown in the parent-child relationship, as the child may feel betrayed and misunderstood. Furthermore, it may not necessarily teach the child about responsibility. Instead, it could instill a fear of forming attachments, as they may fear losing someone they care about as a result of their actions.

Alternatives to Consider

While it’s important for children to learn about responsibility, there are other ways to teach this lesson without causing harm. For instance, parents can:

  • Set clear expectations about the child’s responsibilities towards the pet from the beginning.
  • Implement a reward system for when chores are done, rather than a punishment system for when they’re not.
  • Have open conversations about the importance of responsibility and the consequences of neglecting duties.


In conclusion, while it’s crucial for parents to teach their children about responsibility, it’s equally important to consider the ethical implications and potential consequences of their disciplinary methods. Using a pet as a tool for discipline can cause harm to both the pet and the child, and there are other, more compassionate ways to impart the same lesson.